Building Movement Monitoring: Settlement, Tilt, Cracks and Vibration Compared

An excavation, a dewatering system or a piling rig next to an existing building raises the same question for everyone involved: is the building moving, and if so, how much? No single instrument answers that question, because a building can move in several ways at once.

This article sets the main types of movement side by side, explains which instrument measures which, and shows how they are combined on typical projects.

What is building movement monitoring?

Building movement monitoring means measuring, at fixed points and over a longer period, how a structure moves compared with its position before the work started. The purpose is to see a trend early, while there is still time to adjust the work.

Two kinds of movement have to be kept apart. Slow movement builds up over days or weeks: the building sinks, rotates or a crack opens a little further. Fast movement is vibration: the building shakes for a moment and returns to where it was. They have different causes and different limits, and they need different instruments.

Five types of movement and how they are measured

  1. Settlement: the building sinks.
  2. Tilt: the building rotates.
  3. Crack width: an existing crack opens.
  4. Horizontal displacement: the building shifts sideways.
  5. Vibration: the building shakes briefly and returns.
Movements 1 to 4 are slow and lasting. Movement 5 is fast and temporary.
MovementInstrumentUnitTypical cause
Settlement or heave (vertical)Liquid level settlement system, precise levellingmmExcavation, dewatering, tunnelling
Tilt (rotation)Tiltmeter (tilt sensor)mm/m or degreesUneven settlement, a deflecting retaining wall
Crack widthCrack metermmExisting cracks that open or close
Horizontal displacementTotal station, inclinometermmExcavation next to the foundation
VibrationVibration monitormm/s and HzPiling, sheet piling, demolition, compaction

Groundwater level and pore pressure are often measured as well. They are not a movement of the building, but they explain why settlement occurs and often change before the building does.

Slow movement: settlement, tilt and cracks

Slow movement is followed at fixed points over weeks or months. Three measurements are common, and they complement each other.

  • Settlement points show where and how much the building moves vertically. Automatic systems such as liquid settlement gauges measure this continuously against a stable reference.
  • Tiltmeters on a wall, column or tower register rotation. If one corner of a building settles 5 mm more than a corner 10 metres away, the building has rotated by 0.5 mm per metre between those points.
  • Crack meters across existing cracks show whether a crack is stable or still opening.
Uneven settlement becomes tilt: 5 mm more settlement over 10 metres is 0.5 mm per metre. The drawing is exaggerated.

For the structure, uneven movement matters more than the absolute figure: a building that sinks evenly as a whole rarely cracks, a building that sinks unevenly does. How settlement is measured, including total and differential settlement and the working of a liquid level system, is covered in depth in settlement monitoring explained.

Profound's IS system, including the closed IS liquid levelling system, has been used on monitoring projects for more than 25 years. References include Amsterdam Central Station and Victoria Underground Station in London.

Two sensors of the Profound IS liquid levelling system, connected by liquid-filled tubes
Sensors of the IS liquid levelling system.

Fast movement: where vibration monitoring fits in

Vibration is the fast kind of movement. A vibration monitor on the building records how strongly it shakes during piling, sheet piling or demolition, in mm/s and with the frequency, and compares that with a guideline such as SBR-A or DIN 4150-3.

Vibration and settlement are connected. Continuous vibration can compact loose sand, so that a foundation settles even though the vibration level itself stayed below the limit. Where vibratory work takes place near buildings on shallow foundations, it is therefore sensible to follow both. How vibrations are measured is explained in how to measure vibrations.

Which measurements for which project?

ProjectMain riskUsual combination
Deep excavation next to buildingsSettlement and horizontal movement as the ground relaxesSettlement points, tilt, groundwater level
DewateringSettlement over a wide areaPore pressure or groundwater level, settlement
Pile driving and sheet pilingVibration, and settlement through compactionVibration monitor, settlement points on the nearest facades
Tunnelling under or next to buildingsSettlement trough, differential settlementSettlement, tilt
Demolition next to existing buildingsVibration, loss of supportVibration monitor, crack meters

The table is a starting point, not a prescription. The monitoring plan for a project follows from the risk assessment, the permit and what has been agreed with the neighbours.

Four things every monitoring plan needs

  • A baseline. Start measuring before the work starts. Buildings also move with temperature and season. Without a baseline you cannot tell that movement apart from the effect of the work.
  • A stable reference. Every relative measurement is only as good as the point it is compared with.
  • Warning and intervention levels. Agree in advance at which value someone is warned, at which value the work stops and who decides.
  • One place for the data. Movement only becomes understandable next to the site diary: which activity took place when the trend changed?

What Profound supplies for building monitoring

Profound develops and supplies the measuring equipment. The monitoring plan and the interpretation remain with the responsible engineer.

  • IS system: settlement, pore pressure, load and strain measurements in one network.
  • VIBRA 5+ with the Profound Portal: vibration monitoring with real-time alerts.
  • Through our partners Geosense and Worldsensing: inclinometers, tiltmeters, crack meters and wireless data transfer.

Frequently asked questions about building movement monitoring

What is the difference between movement monitoring and vibration monitoring?

Movement monitoring follows slow, lasting changes such as settlement, tilt and crack width, in millimetres over days or weeks. Vibration monitoring records short, fast movement in mm/s while the work is going on. A building can stay within the vibration limit and still settle, so on many projects both are needed.

How much building movement is acceptable?

There is no general figure. It depends on the structure, the foundation and above all on the difference in movement between points. The limits for a project are set in the monitoring plan by the structural or geotechnical engineer.

Who arranges the monitoring of a building next to a construction site?

Usually the party that carries out or commissions the work, as laid down in the permit or the contract. A specialist sets up the measurements and interprets them. The results are shared with the owner of the building where that has been agreed.

Can one system measure everything?

No. Settlement, tilt, crack width and vibration each need their own sensor. What can be combined is the data: one overview with all measurements next to the progress of the work.

When can monitoring stop?

When the work that causes movement has finished and the measurements show that the movement has stabilised. Settlement can continue for some time after dewatering or excavation has ended, so stopping on the last working day is usually too early.

Monitoring a building next to your project?

Describe the work, the surrounding buildings and what has to be demonstrated. We will tell you which measuring systems fit.